Four questions to ask your agency in the pitch

Earlier this month the extraordinary case of a fake marketing agency was the feature of a BBC expose.

Mad Bird was created entirely online, the people hired were not salaried, had never worked with each other nor even known the founder. It had a convincing website full of great case studies and a confident tone of voice. Yet none of the case studies belonged to the agency. An extreme case of ‘fake it til you make it’ and a timely reminder that when an agency ‘pitches’ to you they’re going to be putting on their best face.  So how can you tell what’s fact and what’s fiction?

Working remotely, when you may not ever meet in person, and almost anyone can create a convincing digital presence, how can you tell the team has what it takes? Having lived in Agency Land for many years, we’ve seen the good, bad, and ugly of agency practices. Here are four questions to ask agencies at pitch phase to help eliminate ‘fake news.

Who worked on that project?
No one loves a neatly-packaged case study or slide of client logos more than an agency. Unfortunately, all too often the person who worked on that impressive project left the business years ago. Asking who worked on the engagement and hearing from them first-hand, ensures you’ll actually benefit from that experience.

What about our brief interests you?
Good consultants spend more time learning about the client than talking about themselves. You’ll be able to feel when the people you’re speaking to have taken the time to understand the intricacies of your business, the unique challenges you’re facing, and are keen to know more. Beware the agency who says they’ve seen it all before.

How do your clients describe you?
Client advocacy is one of the most powerful ways to assess an agency’s strength. If they can answer this question easily, you know they have strong client relationships. Better still, they offer to introduce you directly.

Why do you think we’d work well together?
Yes, the approach, methodology, costing, and project plan are all very important, but if the pitch doesn’t even touch on ways of working together, that can be a serious red flag. Cultural fit is a key way to assess not only if the project will be a success but whether you’ll enjoy it too.

Whilst the Mad Bird example was ‘agency hyperbole’ taken to the extreme, it’s a warning for all of us not to judge others purely by online presence alone.  Asking the right questions at the start can save a lot of pain further down the line.

More Insights

This Christmas, be a Muppet. Post, by The Caffeine Partnership.
  • Inspiration
  • Brand-led Business Strategy

This Christmas, be a Muppet

It’s perhaps overlooked that Kermit is a businessman – or businessfrog. He leads a team which is as about as diverse as you could imagine. What’s more, he’s constantly fighting crises on every front, to keep the business going. There’s a lot we can learn this Christmas from…

Need a shot of Caffeine?

Are you an impatient leader wanting to make things happen?

We can help.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Caffeine's Extra Shot

Sign up here to receive your monthly Extra Shot newsletter.

Privacy Policy
We will only use your email address to send you Extra Shot content and will treat your information with respect. By clicking below, you agree that we may process your information in accordance with these terms. You can change your mind at any time by clicking the unsubscribe link in the footer of any email you receive from us.
We use Mailchimp as our marketing platform. By clicking below to subscribe, you acknowledge that your information will be transferred to Mailchimp for processing. Learn more about Mailchimp's privacy practices here.

Fourth year in a row: The UK's Leading Management Consultants 2023 by the FT. Post, by The Caffeine Partnership.

Awarded the UK’s
Leading Management Consultants 2023
by the Financial Times.

Purpose, Pay or Perks?
What Matters Most to Employees.

Download our FREE White Paper.

We commissioned an independent survey of 1000 UK employees with the objective of understanding how expectations around what they want or expect from work have changed since the pandemic.

Fill in the form below to download our report.