Last week, we worked with a global client wrestling with a challenge many professional services firms now face. For years, this service line didn’t have to go out and get new business.  Instead, clients came knocking, seduced by its scale, reputation, and track record. They came, and they stayed – often for decades.  But a regulatory shake-up has triggered a compulsory client rotation every two years. Now, they’re being swapped out and need to get on the front foot. Cue the need for proactive prospecting. Given that this issue is not unique – is there any company that doesn’t want more new clients? – the time felt right for a quick primer on proactive prospecting. 

This isn’t a ‘how to’ in terms of generating a target list and sending a million emails. It seems that everyone got that memo recently given the state of my in-box. This is more about taking a step back and thinking about your ideal audience and how you can help them.

What is prospecting, really?

Much as we’d like it to be, prospecting isn’t answering a friendly email from an ex-client offering up a juicy project. That’s reactive responding, not sales generation. Real prospecting is generating sales and profit from people who’ve never heard of you – and wouldn’t unless you put yourself in front of them.

The ideal prospect has:

• Budget (money),
• Authority (decision-making power), and
• Desire (a problem you can solve).

Yet, as a classic McGraw-Hill ad put it:

“I don’t know your company. I don’t know your products. I don’t know your reputation. Now, what was it you wanted to sell me?”

Exactly. Prospecting starts with fixing that knowledge gap.

Start with Strategy: Define Your Audience

The biggest prospecting mistake is chasing everyone. You can’t be all things to all people and you shouldn’t even try.

Begin with brand clarity:

• Who are we best placed to help?
• Who will value what we do most?
• Who do we want more of?

Don’t just chase sectors or job titles. Target by attitude. At Caffeine, we go after “impatient leaders” – decision-makers in a hurry to grow their brand, improve their customer experience or positively impact the employee experience. One M&A advisory firm defined its target as “Leaders looking for leaders” – smart, ready-to-move companies looking for trusted direction.

Get the facts: audit your current position

Before rushing out with a new pitch, get brutally honest about where you stand. If the pipeline’s dry, conversions are weak, or growth is stalling, find out why.

Run a ‘situation snapshot’:

• Interview 6–8 current clients, recent prospects, and past losses.
• Use a neutral third party if possible – they’ll get more honesty.
• Ask for clarity, not flattery. Insights are more valuable than compliments.

Ask clients:

• How would you describe us in three words?
• What do we do better – or worse – than competitors?
• What are we not giving you that you want?

Ask internally:

• What’s our proposition and positioning?
• Who are our ideal clients?
• What are we famous for – or want to be?

This internal and external mirror gives you clarity on the value you deliver, where you’re falling short, and what you need to dial up.

Build Your ‘Tell and Sell’

Once you’ve got the insights, it’s time to craft your narrative.

Your ‘Tell’ is your why: Why you exist. What problem are you uniquely positioned to solve? If your firm didn’t exist, why would you invent it?

Your ‘Sell’ is your how: What you offer, how you deliver it, and how it’s different from the rest.

Bring this to life by answering:

• What behaviours make us distinct?
• What evidence backs up our claims?
• What’s our client tone – bold, warm, precise?
• How do we want to be experienced?

And if your answers don’t reflect where you want to be – future-focus it. Ask:

• What should our reputation be?
• What should characterise our client experience?
• What should make our people stand out?

A strong, simple, standout story makes it easier to attract the right clients and repel the wrong ones.

Be brave: say no to the wrong work

The temptation to say “yes” to every enquiry is real. But if the client isn’t in your target zone—wrong level, wrong brief, wrong fit – it’ll cost more than it returns. Stay true to your target and proposition. Focus on the clients who’ll value what you do best. That’s how you grow with purpose.

What This All Means for Prospecting

Let’s recap the truths we need to work with:

• Prospecting is a long game. It’s not about quick wins – it’s about consistent, purposeful pursuit of high-value clients.
• Prospecting must be targeted. Scattergun outreach wastes time and erodes brand value.
• Prospecting isn’t just cold calling or mass emails. It’s research, relevance, relationships and reputation.

Done well, prospecting isn’t just about chasing work. It’s about building your brand, sharpening your focus, and owning your space in the market. That’s how you stop being swapped out and start being sought after.

If you need help with positioning, prospecting or auditing your current business development process, we can help.  And you can read more in Catalyst by Louisa Clarke & David Kean.

Contact: .